On Christmas Eve 2024, a Carroll Gardens writer described her family's Feast of the Seven Fishes in Patch. She fried the baccalĆ fritters herself. The shopping list read like a map of the neighborhood: bread from the Caputo bread store, antipasto from Caputo's Fine Foods, fish from Carroll Gardens Fish Market and cuccidati from Court Pastry. The table had clams, shrimp, smelts, scallops, seafood salad, linguini and lobster tails, and the antipasto included a salted mozzarella.
This December you can't walk that list exactly as written. On April 28, 2026, Caputo's Bake Shop at 329 Court Street lit its oven for the last time. The bakery opened in 1904 and had been in the same family for five generations. December 24 is close enough to start planning the run now. Most of the old route still works. The one big change is where the bread comes from, and lard bread is still baked in Carroll Gardens, a few blocks off Court.
What the closing actually took
James Caputo announced the closing with a sign on the storefront. Brooklyn Paper printed his words: "the flame in our oven has been lit for the last time, and Caputo Bakery has come to the end of its 124-year life." Brooklyn Paper also ran a correction the same night. Caputo's Fine Foods on Court Street is a separate business with no tie to the bakery, despite the shared name. Anyone whose list has both Caputo stops on it should treat them as two businesses.
According to New York Eats Here, the family still owns the building at 329 Court Street. The family's starter went on to a new shop in Park Slope, and a lard bread loaf is still baked a few blocks away on Union Street.
Lard bread is still on Union Street
Mazzola Bakery is at 192 Union Street. Nicolo Mazzola founded it in 1928, according to Patch. Over the years it has added breads, pastries, coffee and breakfast, and it still bakes its signature lard bread with Genoa salami and provolone. Eater NY notes that Carroll Gardens once had many old-school Italian bakeries and only a few remain, with Mazzola at this location since 1928 and known for that same loaf.
Since April, New York Eats Here and The Gowanaut have written about the neighborhood missing Caputo's lard bread. For the Christmas Eve table, the bread stop moves one corner off Court Street, to Mazzola's own loaf.
Court Pastry is the line to plan around
Court Pastry Shop is at 298 Court Street, and The Gowanaut listed its hours in August as daily, 8:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. Salvatore Zerilli bought the shop in 1948, after learning the trade from an uncle who ran a pastry shop on Columbia Street. His sons Gasper and Vincent run it now, and a pink marble table shipped from Italy in the 1890s is still in use in the kitchen.
The Gowanaut says the holidays are the shop's real test. It runs seven days a week, frying rice balls and pulling sfogliatelle from the oven, and the line gets longer the closer it gets to Christmas. People plan trips around the sfogliatelle, orange-scented ricotta in a shell that shatters when you bite it. The shop has also made sugar-free cookies for about twenty years. The 2024 Patch family bought their cuccidati and other Italian Christmas cookies here. Now that Caputo's oven is cold, Court Pastry is the busiest stop on the walk. Holiday-week hours can change from the August listing, so call before a big order.
The 300 block, one door at a time
Walking south from Court Pastry, the block reads like a record of the year. The cold oven at 329 comes first. Pasticceria Monteleone is at 355 Court Street, with Italian cookies, pastries, cakes and gelato. New York Eats Here dates Monteleone's at its address to 1929, and gives D'Amico, roasting coffee since 1948, and Marco Polo, open since 1983, as other long-running names on the strip. A bag of D'Amico coffee is an easy addition for whoever is bringing dessert.
Next door, 357 Court Street was Esposito & Sons Jersey Pork Store. It closed in April 2023 after 100 years in the neighborhood, according to the Brooklyn Eagle. This is the fourth Christmas without it.
A few doors farther, 371 Court Street has the newest Italian name on the street. Il Quartiere is a small Italian shop next to Ven. Space, run by an uncle and his nephew, which The Gowanaut listed as open in late September. Its own site describes a place for a quick plate of pasta, dinner to take home or a seat with friends. It says the name honors the old Italian neighborhood, and it opens with the greeting "Mangiasti?" Did you eat? For a household cooking seven fishes, take-home pasta from a shop a few doors down could cover the night before, or the people who arrive early.
Fish and mozzarella, at either end of the walk
The fish has to come from somewhere, and the 2024 Patch list named Carroll Gardens Fish Market. At the north end of Court Street, Fish Tales at 197 Court Street sells fresh seafood and smoked fish, takes orders by phone and was posting its daily catch in November. Ordering by phone means you aren't counting on the case still holding smelts and scallops at four o'clock on December 24.
For the salted mozzarella on the antipasto plate, MozzLab says it makes fresh mozzarella on site every day at its shop at 502 Henry Street. A 2022 ABC7 feature says the shop also makes burrata, smoked mozzarella and ricotta. MozzLab is part of the street's food scene now too. In September it teamed up with Ramblin' Chick on a chicken parm burger and asked the neighborhood to name it after Carroll Gardens' history and Italian-American roots, as the Court Street Journal reported. Ricotta from Henry Street will also help anyone making struffoli or cookie fillings at home.
The Caputo starter, a short trip away
The Caputo family's bread didn't go far. On October 5, James Caputo opened Caputo Bagels at 81 Fifth Avenue in Park Slope. The dough uses no commercial yeast. It's built on a sourdough starter the shop says is at least 45 years old, the same one his father used on Court Street. His partner is Rafi Hasid, who opened Hill Diner on Court Street in 2002 and bought Caputo's bread wholesale for two decades. The shop has about 25 seats.
The signature is a $4 Lard Bread bagel with salami, lard, provolone, salt and pepper folded into the dough, per New York Eats Here's October report. Brooklyn Magazine called it a hybrid with a looser crumb than a bagel and a crispier crust than bread. As of October it was open 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. on weekdays and 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. on weekends. A loaf for the table is still a Mazzola purchase. A half dozen Lard Bread bagels for Christmas morning, from the Court Street family's starter, is now a Park Slope purchase.
The 2026 route, written out
Put together, the old list rewrites into one walk with one side trip:
- Order fish ahead from Fish Tales, 197 Court Street, and pick it up first.
- Cookies, cuccidati and sfogliatelle at Court Pastry, 298 Court Street, ideally early in the day.
- Lard bread at Mazzola, 192 Union Street.
- Mozzarella and ricotta at MozzLab, 502 Henry Street.
- Pastries, cakes or gelato at Pasticceria Monteleone, 355 Court Street, and coffee from D'Amico.
- Pasta or a take-home dinner at Il Quartiere, 371 Court Street, for the night before.
- On a separate morning, Lard Bread bagels from Caputo Bagels, 81 Fifth Avenue.
Holiday hours and order cutoffs can differ from the regular schedule, so call each shop in the first half of December.
In many Carroll Gardens families, the Christmas Eve run has been handed down along with the house on the block. If this is the first December you're making that walk for a parent or grandparent who used to, and the family home is part of what you're now sorting through, Ronit Abraham works with heirs and executors on these brownstones with patience and care. When you're ready, request a complimentary market or probate consultation, and we can talk through the house at your family's own pace.